<img src=images/arroww.gif width=9 height=9> The Community Site

Search Business Directory:  Add your business entry
 Community Magazine

 South Downs National Park

 Local News
 Local Events
 Local Traffic
 Local Trains
 Local Weather

 Give Blood

 About Liphook

 Local MP
 Parish Council

 Bike Ride
 Day Centre
 Heritage Centre
 In Bloom
 Millennium Ctr
 Neighbourhood Plan


 Clubs & Societies
 Local churches
 Local shops
 New Mums & Dads
 Useful Contacts

 Food & Drink
 Places to Visit
 Tesla chargers

 Website Links
 Online Directory
 Add Entry
 Edit Entry
 Business Help
 Web Design
 Privacy Policy
 About Us

Local Talkback
Talkback is for the residents and businesses in Liphook to voice their views and opinions about local issues and events.

Reply to THIS thread
Start a NEW Talkback Thread
Talkback Home

Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (6th Mar 2019 @ 06:56:12)

I stumbled across this when I was checking the dates for the next elections. I was really surprised to see that there is less than a month until nomination papers have to be in and we have not heard anything about this locally.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Phelim McIntyre (8th Mar 2019 @ 13:19:39)

May be the current Council are so sure of the threat to their power with the ongoing charges against Jerrard, with so many having supported him, they are frightened that people will rise up and vote them off.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (8th Mar 2019 @ 16:44:30)

It is not really a question of “voting them off”. In order to be successful in making sure the “trouble makers” do not get elected in May enough people would have to stand and poll more votes than they do – this is always supposing they will stand for election in May. If enough people do not stand for election– there are 12 vacancies – then the “trouble makers”, if they are standing again, will automatically get on the Parish Council by default as there would be no election.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- BT (9th Mar 2019 @ 09:16:17)

Where can I find a list of who is standing for the elections with a clear ( short) statement of what their interests and aims are for the locality ?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Keith (9th Mar 2019 @ 09:49:30)

A full list of persons nominated will be available on the EHDC website from 4th April 2019.

This will simply be a list of persons nominated (and where appropriate the political party they represent).

The Herald usually runs a couple of pages on the lead up to the elections with a photo of each candidate and a couple of paragraphs from each candidate on what they stand for. As far as I'm aware there is no online source you can go to which provides this sort of information.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (9th Mar 2019 @ 10:17:30)

A list of candidates standing for election in May will be published after the closing date for nominations. The closing date I think is 32 days before Polling Day. Each candidate should publish an election address after this date which usually gives details of their background, family, business, aims for the parish etc etc. Some candidates will have been on the parish/district council and will be standing again so one could read minutes published over the past 4 years and also see on which committees they have been serving. In the case of Cllr Jerrard, and I don’t know whether he will be standing again, he has been found guilty by The Governance, Audit & Scrutiny Sub-Committee on 6 out of 7 breaches of the Members Code of Conduct which speaks for itself although I doubt whether he will put this in his election address.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- John (9th Mar 2019 @ 11:20:00)

Sometimes it is easy to label people trouble makers. It is not the school playground and perhaps letting the status quo go unchallenged is not a good idea.
That way it is easy for a dictatorship to exist.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- KT (9th Mar 2019 @ 21:03:03)

There are 12 seats on Liphook Parish Council and if 12 or less people put their names forward then those people will be automatically elected with no opportunity for residents to vote. This means that it is likely that Jerrard and his small clique may well get elected again.

So what we need are more than 12 putting their names forward so we at least get a choice and have a vote.

If anyone is in any doubt whether Jerrard deserves to be elected then please have a look at the link below:

Also take note of the fact that he keeps saying that he is ill and can't attend meetings etc due to stress. Not much use really if you're going to be representing your community (actually in his case he doesn't live here so he can't really represent what he doesn't know).

The date to get nominations in is 3rd April. If anyone is thinking of standing then they can contact EHDC Electoral Services or phone the Parish Office in Liphook who will be able to give out information. Election notices should also be posted on Friday 22nd March and hopefully these will be on all the noticeboards and will contain information about how to apply.

Let's hope we get a parish council that will give us what we need and deserve!

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- john (9th Mar 2019 @ 23:16:50)

The Parish council has very little power. Perhaps " Giving us what we need" is a very broad statement, the District Council has a lot more power they are the ones giving us more and more houses make no mistake, not the Parish Council. Is that really what we need?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (12th Mar 2019 @ 14:30:41)

Unfortunately, those labelled as 'trouble makers' are often the minority who are sticking to their guns about an issue which they are passionate about. It doesn't make them trouble, it does mean that they have stood on a particular platform and won't be budged from it.

Our Parish Council does' in truth' have very little real power, however, this fact will not stop petty-minded people focused on getting their own way from kicking up a stink when their agendas are blocked - regardless of how 'small' their agendas are.

Sadly, these are the 'stories' that reach the local rag and consequently the reason that the reputation of the Parish Council is often dragged through the mire. Also, the same reason that right-minded people in the village won't stand for election. a lot of work, a lot of people stabbing you in the back to get very little achieved and all at the risk of your own personal reputation being destroyed and for ZERO remuneration.

It really has got to the point where instead of asking why people don't want to stand (obvious), you have to ask what connections every candidate has with all of the main property owners and house builders in the area and therefore have the knowledge [upfront] what agendas and what bits of land they are there to fight for houses on.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- John (13th Mar 2019 @ 00:18:11)

I do not think it is the Parish Councillors who have the land agendas, but the district councillors. They will never come clean on their interests, in the same way they do not make very public their Limited Company started and funded with council tax payers money which bought thr OSU
business site amongst other things, because no other company was interested to buy and build on it.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- KT (13th Mar 2019 @ 16:37:20)

I think Dawn Hoskins post shows a complete lack of understanding about what a parish councillor does if she really thinks that the most important thing to know about potential councillors is if they have allegiances to particular property developers. There are certain people on the council who share her view but this is such a negative, uninformed view. From the councillors that I know they have no allegiances to any property developers and neither did the ones that have recently resigned. But that particular line suits particular councillors and they keep banging on about it.

What is far more important surely is that individuals stand as councillors who really want to make a difference in their community - the parish council is about so much more than housing and development. Don't forget that the parish council is only a consultee on planning applications and does not decide them - that's a job for the district council.

What is more important surely is the emerging Neighbourhood Plan, the public open spaces owned and run by the parish council, the Milennium Centre and events run there for the benefit of the village, the parish office which provides an information resource, the spending of developers contributions for the benefit of the community, working with other community organisations to provide services in the village, and so on? I'd llike to see people stand as councillors who have a keen interest in some or all of these things.

It's such a shame that the parish council has got such a bad name but you have to ask yourself when did it acquire this bad name? Was it about the same time as particular councillors were elected back in 2011 who brought much unrest and turned the council upside down in their quest to fire the then Clerk? Are these the same councillors that are still serving now who are failing to turn up to meetings and clearly have their own agendas as they seem to have nothing to contribute other than causing trouble for others? Look at the resignations over the last year - decent hard working councillors who couldn't take the barrage of abuse they suffered.

What it needs is a whole new bunch of councillors coming forward who can bring about real change. We really need to have an election and we will only get that if more than 12 people put their names forward so I would urge anyone thinking about it to do so. If this doesn't happen the council will just continue to limp along making little progress for another 4 years.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- ex-pc (14th Mar 2019 @ 12:26:10)

I think you’’ find that Dawn Hoskins was a councillor for a few years and has a very good understanding of what it is a bout.
You aksed about the bad name – for that you only have to ask the staff whov worked for the PC [or did] over the last few years.
Theyre lives were made absolute hell, many lbeing made sick with stress after being bullied and may just walking our who. At the same time the sme person who was making their lives bl**dy hell, was making money claims left right and centre to top u[ his wages and making formal complaints about anyone who tried to stand up to him.
Maybe make a feedom of imofmation reqest for how many ficticitous claims he made and how much money he made out of the council by threatening to use thme. Or – even better, make a request for the documents which your all paied for out fo your taxes for the investigations into him. Anything paid for out of our taxes is a public document so you have all rights to ask for it. I expc they’’ take out everyones names so you can’t understand it properly but you would at elast get to the truth of the pure bl**dy hell that everyone at the PC went through at the time and understand how the PC got a bad reputation.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (14th Mar 2019 @ 13:09:45)

Hi KT – I don’t know you’re real name – but I will continue to use mine.

I was a Parish Councillor for BLPC so have very good insight. My position remains unchanged at the moment with regards to vested interests into property deals and plonking hundreds more houses in Liphook.

It is my understanding that we currently have people involved with both the Parish Council and the Neighbourhood Plan who are employed by property developers or live in housing provided to them at peppercorn rents by property developers.

When people/councillors have objected to this they have been ‘closed down’.

This is a totally unacceptable situation.

It is, and always has been, imperative that anyone connected to any decision (with even a remote connection to any decision being made) must recuse themselves. [Not take part]. This is administrative law which has been relied on for hundreds of years to protect the public from biased decision making and must stand in relation to any decisions which the public could reasonably draw a conclusion that connected-persons were biased.

It is also my understanding that some councillors have been prevented from either accessing meetings or accessing information. It is imperative that all councillors have full access to all information. No one should be banned or have their access prohibited because they hold a different opinion, particularly with regard to planning issues.

Our District Councillors are outspoken in their support of building evermore housing, and in particular, wanting to build on the SDNP. Although this is disagreeable, it is understandable as central government wants all councils to build more housing.

However, it is up to the Parish Council to draw the line in the sand. As head of EHDC [Ferris Cowper] once said: “Liphook is Full”. Enough is enough.

Our Parish Councillors need to have enough backbone to stand up for what they personally believe without fear of reprisal. More importantly, our Parish Councillors must ensure that the council adheres to what administrative law dictates and, sadly, anyone doing that at the moment is accused of either derailing meetings, or being a bully.

We have seen a sad return to the days when everyone crept about in fear of yet another legal threat or formal complaint being made about them [both councillors and employees alike]. This is an incredible waste of everyone’s time, but also costs thousands of pounds.

When I left the PC, it had been transformed from a hideous toxic environment to a really collegiate and supportive place, in which the staff were finally happy after many years of being traumatised. We went from the laughing stock who regularly had stories fed to the local rag from the same source which were, quite honestly, a journalistic travesty, full of one-sided poison – to a regular Parish Council with contented staff and a proactive team of volunteers. It did take time to do this and effectively create a root and branch transformation which instilled and promoted respect, but we achieved it.

I don’t know what the answer is, I truly don’t. As a Parish, we have many assets that need to be maintained and staffed – so it is better for us to do this as local people who are directly affected by changes in our neighbourhoods. However, we have now moved into a period of apathy and general disinterest. People seem ‘too busy’ to be interested and the dwindling teams of volunteers we do have [not just parish councillors, but Bloomers and litter pickers etc] are constantly ‘second-guessed’ by people who have never been to a meeting, never turned up to lend a hand, but are quite happy to slag them off at every opportunity.

It is the exact definition of a thankless task. However, it is even worse than not being thanked - because you are likely to get ‘slated’ for even showing up and having an opinion.

I truly don’t know how to fix it.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (14th Mar 2019 @ 14:03:20)

Dawn this is a serious allegation ie quote "It is my understanding that we currently have people involved with both the Parish Council and the Neighbourhood Plan who are employed by property developers or live in housing provided to them at peppercorn rents by property developers." Have you names to verify this? Also what is your feeling about Mr Jerrard being found guilty by a completely independent body on 6 out 7 counts of breaches of The Code of Conduct ie bullying, intimidating and harassing fellow councillors. Should he not have resigned? He certainly he should not stand again.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jane Ives (14th Mar 2019 @ 14:44:15)

I am personally appalled at Dawn Hoskins post accusing parish councillors and NDP members of wrong doing. In all my time on the council (which is much more recent than yours Dawn) I saw no evidence of this and nor do I believe it to be true. I was also on the working party who approved NDP steering group members and I can assure you they were properly vetted.
If what you say is true then clearly you should be reporting this to the Clerk of the council for starters and to EHDC if you're talking about a councillor.
I will say hand on heart that I don't believe this to true and to make unfounded accusations on a public website is quite frankly in appalling bad taste.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- john (14th Mar 2019 @ 20:31:07)

A previous poster on here has said that people should not concentrate on worrying about councillor's property connections, it did not matter. You cannot have it both ways, either it is important or it is not.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- ben (14th Mar 2019 @ 20:59:10)

IT is worse now than it has ever been

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (15th Mar 2019 @ 07:51:38)

KT, I entirely agree with you.

Many of us could see the crash coming when the new crew came on board some years ago. The train is upside down and damaged beyond repair and the track is mangled. The passengers are fed up with the train failing to stop at stations and then screeching to a halt in the middle of nowhere without explanation and there is no WiFi! The crew will not listen and most of them are temporary replacements anyway. Some of them ignore announcements and constantly argue about which way to go at the next set of points. After a secret discussion, the driver then makes the wrong choice and tells the passengers it’s too bad anyway. The guard is bewildered and does nothing about it, looking like a frightened rabbit caught in a set of headlights. Understandably, some of the crew down tools and get off at the next station.

How to fix it - new company, new train, new track, new timetable and most importantly a completely new crew who are interested in the passengers. We have a vote but need to use it wisely.

Dawn Hoskins, could you provide us with the evidence in support of what appears to be a quite outrageous statement. Your root and branch transformation failed miserably because the tree was full of decay.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (15th Mar 2019 @ 12:28:29)

Legal confidentiality prevents me from elaborating further. Suffice it to say, based on the facts that we are all given and the input we all receive – we are all entitled to reach our own conclusions.

We all need to be able to detach fact from personal attachments. Just because a friend tells you something – it does not make it true etc

Unfortunately, on threads such as these, the people who respond most vociferously are those who already hold entrenched positions and believe-systems, not always based on facts – but who are nonetheless willing to ‘shut-down’ anyone with dissenting views.

I hold, what many people consider to be a dissenting view. The nature of a democratic society with freedom of speech is both a benefit and a curse – it enables vitriolic and poisonous speech, internet trolls and anonymous keyboard comment – but it also allows me to state my conclusions and opinions regardless of the outrage it may cause some.

It is also the reason most people just won’t get involved, or make any comment on threads like these – fear of harsh words in response. The same reason that people are 'turned off' politics [Parish, District, County or UK as a whole ]

I don’t agree with the comment by Anon2 about the root and branch change that was accomplished as being a failure. If a system is working properly it is incumbent on those inheriting the working system to keep it working. You cannot say that it was not working before; only that is has been broken again now.

[Maybe you should ask the staff as one previous poster has inferred - they have an inside line on most of the goings on at the council and although they may not post here - they are all quite easy to find].

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Another Resident (15th Mar 2019 @ 17:18:08)

Well... I have heard it all now. Over the last few years I have come to the conclusion that there is a core in the parish council that is rotten. Having been to several meetings there are definitely those that seem to have an agenda.

When it comes down to housing developments I have seen the most appalling attitudes that really have made me wonder.

I have had dealings with our District councillors and have found them the most helpful of people. I have nothing but faith in them.

Again it comes down to those preventing anything being built in the National park when it was plainly obvious that the majority of people favoured it and not have developments built further out of Liphook.

As for saying no more housing in Liphook. Ideally no, but is it going to happen ? As sure as the sun comes up tomorrow.

I have seen these parish councillors with my own eyes at a meeting in Midhurst a few years ago. They basically over ruled what the District councillors and what the public preferred, including I might add doctors too.
As to why, this has been a burning question I can not fathom.

Is Dawn Hoskins right ? How legitimate are her words? if they are to be believed then this is extremely serious. She says legal confidentiality prevents her from saying more, but if it is illegal surely it should be brought into the public domain.

I wouldn't be the first one to have had thoughts on this type of agenda, so I hope there is a way for this to be checked out.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- John (15th Mar 2019 @ 18:08:15)

I think people are comfusing a desire not to build in Liphooks corner of the
SdNp with corruption. I believe that the developers reffered to are those who
want to sell two huge pieces of land in the Park, and their close links to the District
Council. The EHDC area is a seperate planning authority and does not have any power to allow building there.That is what upsets them.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (16th Mar 2019 @ 11:24:24)

Dawn with regard to your statement that legal confidentially prevents you from naming names I think this is absolute rubbish. It is far more likely that you are worried about libel laws because I do not believe that there are or have been people involved with the PC and the NDP who are either employed by the property developers or live in housing provided by them. I think Jane Ives, having recently been a councillor on the PC is in a far better position to know that what you say is untrue. Interestingly you use the word “people” and not “councillors”.
I entirely agree with Anon 2 regarding the “root and branch change as being a failure.” I would go further and say that the parish council is in a worse situation now than it was before. In fact I do not remember a time, after the Clerk was dismissed, when the PC was a “really collegiate and supportive place.” It was peppered with exempt and secret meetings for a start. If you seek to change anything council, government, policies or laws you have to be sure that something better will take its place. That has not happened on this parish council. As Ben said in his post “ It is worse now than it has ever been”.
You say that “Our Parish Councillors need to have enough backbone to stand up for what they personally believe without fear of reprisal. More importantly, our Parish Councillors must ensure that the council adheres to what administrative law dictates and, sadly, anyone doing that at the moment is accused of either derailing meetings, or being a bully.” Your statement demonstrates very clearly that although you have been on the PC in the past, you patently do not understand or do not want to understand what has been going on in the past 4 years. You ignore the fact that Mr Jerrard was found guilty on 6 out 7 breaches of the Code of Conduct by the Governance, Audit and Scrutiny Sub Committee. His bullying and intimidating behaviour to fellow councillors was unacceptable to say the least and cannot be justified under any circumstances whatever he was trying to prove or say. With regard to your statement that “we have now moved into a period of apathy and general disinterest”.I would say that people just get fed up with the “same old, same old” and like Brexit they just switch off. If in the May election twelve good and honest people with no hidden agendas stand and get voted on to the PC then I think we will see real change. If not things will just on as they have done in a horrible toxic environment.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jane Ives (16th Mar 2019 @ 14:01:21)

Dawn I am really concerned about what you are saying here. If you say that you can't disclose information about a parish councillor because of 'legal confidentiality' then surely you must know this is not right?

As you know the office of a parish councillor is a public office and every councillor has to disclose any pecuniary interest. This information is publicly available on both the parish council and district council websites. The link to Bramshott & Liphook parish councillors pecuniary interests is here:

Using this link you can access all of the pecuniary (financial) interests of every parish councillor. The only one who has a link to a potential development site is Cllr Trotter who lives on Bohunt Manor land - the much disputed piece of land in the national park. This means that Cllr Trotter should not be taking part in any discussion or commenting on any matters relating to this piece of land.

If what you are saying is true Dawn, and a councillor has failed to disclose something then I strongly suggest this is reported to the Monitoring Officer at EHDC to investigate. This would be the correct course of action rather than making a sweeping statement on a public website about councillors in general.

(To ensure complete transparency, NDP Steering Group members were also asked to complete similar paperwork but theirs is not a public office and therefore it should not be in the public domain but it is vetted).

You also say the following:
"We all need to be able to detach fact from personal attachments. Just because a friend tells you something – it does not make it true etc". If you have facts and evidence to support your claims then please take it to the correct authority. If you have heard this from a friend and it is hearsay then maybe you should check these facts before posting here.

As many will know I resigned from the parish council last year but I do not believe that there are parish councillors/NDP steerig group members with undeclared pecuniary interests and I do not feel it is appropriate to make unfounded claims on a public website like you have done.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jeannie (16th Mar 2019 @ 18:14:14)

I agree heartily with Penny and Jane. I heartily disagree with Dawn's statement that the people who respond most vociferously are those who already hold entrenched positions. What a misconceived and arrogant statement. I for one do not feel I am in an "entrenched" position, but I have seen some reprehensible behaviour at parish council meetings and since Michael Croucher has taken the Chair some badly run ones, bordering on the chaotic.

Dawn also states quite rightly that freedom of speech can be a benefit or a curse as it enables vitriolic and poisonous speech, internet trolls and anonymous keyboard comment. However just because we can, does not mean we should and it is usually only the unintelligent or those with an axe to grind who stoop so low. As Jane Ives said Dawn, if you have evidence wrongdoing then report this to the appropriate authority, do not emulate the internet trolls.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Marian (16th Mar 2019 @ 19:57:09)

I cannot believe your posting of 15 March Dawn. Nobody posts on this website as often and as stridently as you. You have a strong opinion on many diverse subjects. On this occasion you have made allegations about parish and district councillors- then hidden behind 'legal cofidententiallity when asked to substantiate your claims. Exactly whose legal interests are you representing? I'm sure we would all be interested to know.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- john (16th Mar 2019 @ 21:48:44)

I was concerned reading something in Jane Ive's posting? she said that Bohunt Manor was a development site? Have the SDNPA not discounted
this as a site for development ? I thought the sites were Headley Road and Chiltley Lane? 14

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jane Ives (17th Mar 2019 @ 10:30:41)

Sorry John that was a bit misleading. It is highly unlikely to be developed at the moment..i meant that it was a potential site and that's really more of an historic thing.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- oldie (17th Mar 2019 @ 13:50:54)

I like the phrase currently non potential development sites, we used to call them fields, or just countryside. I say this whilst sitting in my potential development site wondering whether to plant some roses or a house. I'm lucky to be sitting here looking over the fence at my neighbours horses running around their potential development site and wondering whether to have an afternoon nap or go for a brisk walk through some of the rolling potential development areas surrounding Liphook. When we moved out of London we told the estate agent we'd like a house with a garage and a large potential development site, he said you won't go wrong with these lawns. (OK I'll stop now and have my meds). PS I'm only pulling your leg Jane I know it was a 'slip of the tongue' and I'm no stranger when it comes to that, I think folk are just a little on edge wondering whether this beautiful part of the world has recently been designated an overflow district by our lovely Tory government!

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jane Ives (17th Mar 2019 @ 16:09:02)

Haha Oldie don't worry I have a sense of humour :) It's a very necessary trait on this is picking your words very carefully! ;)

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (17th Mar 2019 @ 16:24:46)

Dawn Hoskins, you are quite at liberty to have dissenting views. In my opinion your strident (I agree Marian), arrogant, and somewhat dictatorial tone will not find favour or influence people and probably didn’t help when you were on the Council. You appear to have no concerns over damaging people’s reputation at whatever cost, which is worrying and rather distasteful.

I am not persuaded by your cry of confidentiality which you are probably hiding under, to protect yourself from digging a deeper hole. I believe you are acting most irresponsibly if you don’t make the appropriate reports to the relevant authorities about such serious claims.

You have made no comment about Cllr Jerrard’s conduct and the recent findings made against him. Your silence in this respect is deafening. What is your view about his behaviour and conduct? Who is being banned from attending Council meetings?

I have asked around, and have found out some interesting information. Apparently, Cllr Garnett appeared on the TV programme “Homes under the Hammer” when she was doing up a property in the north. I see no relevancy in this whatsoever to your outrageous statement about property developers, if that is what you were talking abut. I do not know Cllr Garnett, but I am sure that as a retired Barrister, she would act in an honourable and professional way and have no reason to think otherwise. Also, In October 2014, the Council, which in your words was a “regular Parish Council with contented staff” paid £17,000 to a member of staff that worked in the Millennium Hall, in settlement of a dispute with the Council. It is understood this was about a failed administrative process. That was an expensive failure! Since then, significant numbers of both councillors and staff have resigned. Reasons include the pervading toxicity, bullying and harassment, the sheer unpleasantness of the environment, and frustration over lack of action by the Council.

In my opinion the Council did change in your time. It degenerated, and laid the foundation for what it is now an now a large and unseemly mess.

There is a window of opportunity to change it all at the forthcoming Parish Council elections. Let’s hope some new people will stand and there are 13 or more nominations, enough to ensure an election. We then won’t have to accept councillors being foisted on the community, and there will be a chance to vote.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (19th Mar 2019 @ 13:13:44)

Dawn, why have you not responded to the posters who are genuinely concerned and shocked by the accusations contained in your posts. People’s lives are damaged by people like yourself who think it is perfectly right, because freedom of speech allows them, to make accusations that cannot be substantiated. It is not about just causing outrage – that can be coped with, but to cast slurs and create suspicion on innocent people can have life changing consequences. I think Jane Ives and others have suffered enough in the past at the hands of Mr Jerrard and yet you make no comment about the fact that he has been found guilty on 6 out of 7 breaches of The Code of Conduct. Instead you prefer to belittle, besmirch and defame councillors and people in general without apparently a grain of proof. If you really believe what you have posted here then please confirm publicly on this Site since your accusations originated here, that you have reported these “people” to the appropriate authority. In this way councillors and others who are innocent can breathe a sigh of relief because the Governance, Audit and Scrutiny will take action and the guilty will be named as has happened in the case of Mr Jerrard.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (19th Mar 2019 @ 14:26:01)

Hi Anon2

I do write using quite precise language. I suppose this stems from years of legal drafting. I apologise if you find it arrogant - but don't think I am an arrogant person in general - it is just my word choice I suppose.

I was friends with pretty much everyone on the council in the years that I was there, including all the staff - so I don't think my writing style had any effect on my personal relationships - but thank you for being concerned about it.

I have made it quite clear that I am not going to name names due to legal reasons so have no idea what you are talking about when you say that I have damaged the reputation of any person[s].

If you can find a place where I have done that please repost it so that I can make further comment.

Again, for legal reasons, I cannot comment on the procedure that was conducted which found Cllr Jerrard guilty in his absence. Not the complaints nor the grounds for those complaints, other than to say that there are voice recordings for all of the meetings for which the allegations were made, which despite being offered were not heard by the decision makers in this administrative process.

Please feel free to ask Cllr Jerrard for the sound file and transcript - I am very sure he will oblige.

I can confirm that all of these issues have been reported to the relevant authorities but again I cannot comment further on this.

You are correct in your investigations that damages/payments were made [out of court] to staff members who suffered at the hands of the PC administration, but you have missed all of the other payments. I think that you would need to see the reports of the HR specialists that were bought in to deal with the issue to understand it fully. Redacted copies should be available as they were paid for by the parishioners, but you would not be able to see the names of the parties involved - only read between the lines.

As you know, I am outspoken in my opinion so you should not doubt that if I were able, at this time, to name names - I would. I think you will find that I am one of the few posters here that gives my genuine thoughts using my genuine name (unlike yourself) - so you have very little to back yourself with when you accuse me of deliberately hiding.

I agree that new blood is needed and really hope, very much, that plenty of new candidates step forward for the Parish Council elections.

Perhaps you would like to stand yourself - although Anon2 won't cut the mustard when you fill in the form.

When you stop deliberately hiding being a fake identity - perhaps we can talk more on the subject?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Marian (19th Mar 2019 @ 19:32:17)

I think we should all be interested to know Dawn, how you come by all this information - and which legal confidentiality then prevents you from naming names. It is a long time since you were a Parish Councillor so where is all your insight into the workings of the Parish Council coming from?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Bdavies (20th Mar 2019 @ 12:17:53)

Anyone who thinks that property companies do not have influence on district and parish Councillors and that that there is never a degree of 'collaboration' when it comes to inappropriate building being given the nod-through is living in a fantasy world.
Here is an example.
EHDC refuse to ask the owners of Bohunt Manor, who have left the southern approach to the town in an unacceptable state, to clear it up. The hedgerow and the remaining metal fencing is an eyesore; we all know it is and so do the council.
The reason?
EHDC want building to happen on that part of the national park as it solves a lot of housing quota problems for them. EHDC think that the planning application is still open and therefore the owner is not required to make good.

Did EHDC collude with the owners over the famous change of use scam involving the siting of a wonderful new Exclusive Brethren Gospel Hall that Liphook so badly needed?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny (20th Mar 2019 @ 14:36:00)

Dawn, You say that “I can confirm that all of these issues have been reported to the relevant authorities but again I cannot comment further on this.” I assume you are referring to Mr Jerrard and his convictions of being found guilty of his bullying and harassment of fellow councillors, not to the people involved with both the PC and the NDP whom you have accused in a previous post of being “hand in glove” with the developers ie bribery. Please confirm to what you are referring.

You have been accused of damaging reputations and you request that a re-post is made so that you can make further comment. Your statement which prompted this accusation is as follows: “It is my understanding that we currently have people involved with both the Parish Council and the Neighbourhood Plan who are employed by property developers or live in housing provided to them at peppercorn rents by property developers.” This statement is potentially damaging to everyone involved with the PC and NDP. By making this appalling and unfounded statement you have cast a cloud over the whole of the PC and the NDP because nobody knows to what or to whom you are referring. This is extremely damaging to those innocent folk who not only have had to put up with Mr Jerrard’s behaviour for years, but now, by courtesy of yourself, have a cloud of suspicion hanging over them. Please do the right thing if you have not already done so, Dawn - if you have evidence of wrongdoing, report it to the appropriate authorities.

I am very tired of your oft-posted mantra about people hiding behind fake identities. Very, very few people of this site post with their real names. Some chose outlandish ones, some just first names and some with Christian and surnames. My point is Dawn, how many of the posters who post on this site use their real names - I suspect very few, - so please do not pick on the one or two who happen to disagree with you. In addition I find it almost laughable that you, who won’t name names yourself and hide behind legal confidentiality, should have the gall to accuse others of hiding behind fake names. Pot and kettle come to mind.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (20th Mar 2019 @ 17:07:47)

Hi Penny

IMO the term 'people involved' damages no one's reputation in particular - I was asking for a post in which I accuse and individual person and thereby damage their reputation. Please, if possible, find that for me and I will heartily apologise.

Also, ANYONE not prepared to give their name when they are accusing a person who has identified themselves of 'hiding' deserves to be laughed at.

If you don't have the gumption to identify yourself when you give an opinion then you clearly don't have courage in your convictions.

It is my belief that everyone should have the courage their own convictions, how else can anyone believe that you are acting or behaving in accordance with your ideologies. It is doubly important to have faith in your beliefs and ideologies when you face criticism. If you believe it - say it. It should not matter to you what other people think if you know that you are holding true to your beliefs.

Sadly there are too many 'ringers' that use this site to stir up trouble and effectively 'have conversations with themselves' to benefit their argument.

So anyone using any stupid made-up fake identity - well that's fine, be a coward and hide behind your keyboard - but don't accuse me of hiding when I'm posting in a way that is transparent and honest.

Being 'mock' appalled when you've called yourself Anon is wholly meaningless.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (20th Mar 2019 @ 17:37:43)

Dawn Hoskins, thank you for your reply which leaves me none the wiser as to the answer to my questions.

It is not actually clear whether you have reported the matters in your original statement which was “it is my understanding that we currently have people involved with both the Parish Council and the Neighbourhood Plan who are employed by property developers or live in housing provided to them at peppercorn rents by property developers”. Or is it the issues you state about the procedures and complaints in Cllr Jerrard’s case. You do not say whether you made the reports. There is a lot of obscuration going on, typically legal in its nature. From what you say, I suspect that you have been helping or working with Cllr Jerrard, hence your reticence to provide evidence or explanation in support of your original statement. That is why you have all the inside information, to which Marian refers. People are questioning your statement in this thread not Cllr Jerrard or anyone else.

By making accusations against councillors/members of the NDP group in the way you did on a public forum, you automatically damage their reputations because people will think councillors or individuals have done something wrong. It spreads doubt, suspicion and fear, raises questions and uncertainty, and undermines individuals and their standing in the community. In my opinion, that was the intention and the damage has now been done. You will have offended a number of people.

I am interested in the £17,000 out of court settlement paid to a member of staff in October 2014, because it was a cock-up in an administrative process. It was obviously being hidden under the carpet. It must have been a cock-up by the Council of monumental proportions to warrant £17,000 to be paid out. I trust this cock-up was investigated thoroughly, and appropriate action taken against the perpetrator/s. I do not believe that publishing internal HR or any other reports in relation to that settlement would be appropriate. Any other costs such as legal fees in relation to that cock-up should be made available. The Willows Nursery could have been repaired for that amount and kept open.

I feel entirely safe using Anon2 on this site. You are the only person being rude about it, or having a go at me. At least it means I can’t be doorstepped or pursued by Cllr Jerrard, antics that people have known about for some time and have at last been been exposed. As to the elections, I am well past my sell by date and my blood is far from new.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Marian (20th Mar 2019 @ 19:52:57)

Dawn, If you have been passed confidential information by a member of the Parish Council it seems to me you are showing a lack of professionalism by posting on this site, on this subject at all. There are times when a professional knows to keep their own counsel. You are, after all, not giving facts but dealing in innuendo.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny Williamson (21st Mar 2019 @ 14:14:03)

I have now posted my surname – does that make you feel any better? As Anon2 says let’s hope that I now won’t be doorstepped or pursued by Mr Jerrard, antics that people have known about for some time and have at last been been exposed. I have heard that these unsavoury practices are a speciality of his.

As Anon2 has stated by making accusations against councillors or members of the NDP on this site you have damaged the reputations of all those involved in the PC and the NDP as the whole council and the NDP will be under suspicion. The old adage “no smoke without fire” springs to mind. If you cannot see that then I am very sorry for you. You are the one who lacks the courage to report this to the appropriate authority.

What does your statement “Sadly there are too many 'ringers' that use this site to stir up trouble and effectively 'have conversations with themselves' to benefit their argument. “ mean? Please elucidate, I genuinely don’t know what you are talking about.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Dawn Hoskins (22nd Mar 2019 @ 09:58:55)

How many times must it be stated that these issues HAVE been reported to all relevant authorities?

You've never heard of a ringer?

Also, one more thing. It has never been a crime in this country or anywhere else for that matter, to post mail by hand instead of putting a stamp on it. I regularly do this if I am driving by an address I want to deliver to.

I think this is what you refer to 'doorstepping'?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- K.T. (22nd Mar 2019 @ 13:01:17)

Doorstepping is also lurking around in someone's garden or street to watch who's going in and out.

And just for clarity Dawn, are you saying that where you believe councillors, or NDP steering group members, are living in houses owned by developers where they are paying a peppercorn rent, you have reported this to the Monitoring Officer at EHDC?

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- John R (22nd Mar 2019 @ 14:48:13)

I am involved with the NDP and can confirm that I am neither employed by any developer nor do I live in a 'peppercorn' rent house.

If one of these is available though, please let me know so that I can reduce my monthly outgoings. Something with a nice big garage and 4 bedrooms would be ideal, swimming pool preferred but not essential.

It's great volunteering for things locally :-)

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Penny Williamson (23rd Mar 2019 @ 10:08:54)

I have googled ringer as in spite of my request you did not explain what it meant or should I say what you meant by it. Google definition is as follows:” Ringer. Slang . a racehorse, athlete, or the like entered in a competition under false representation as to identity or ability. a student paid by another to take an exam.” I think I have worked out what you are saying ie some posts are being posted by the same person under different names. However as I do not assume that every poster who disagrees with me has a hidden agenda or is posting more than once under a different name, it took me a little time to work this out. What a very suspicious person you are – it has never occurred to me – I wonder why it has occurred to you.
Your opening question “How many times must it be stated that these issues HAVE been reported to all relevant authorities?” amazed me. This is the first time you have stated on this site that the issues to which you refer have been reported to the relevant authorities. Hopefully now as you say the issues have been reported, the guilty will be brought to justice thus clearing the names of all the innocents.

Doorstepping is not delivering mail by hand as you well know. What has been happening is “stalking” and sitting in a parked car spying. We all know it has been happening so please don’t try to defend or muddy the waters. You are playing with peoples’ lives Dawn demonstrated by John R’s post where he feels a need to protest his innocence. Normally I don’t appreciate sarcasm but in this case it was amply justified. People such as yourself are putting off members of the public from volunteering. I know that I wouldn’t touch B&LPC as it is at the moment with a barge pole.

However on a more positive note Bramshott and Liphook are lucky to have such excellent district councillors in Bill Mouland and Angela Glass. Let us hope they stand again for the sake of the parish. I don’t hold much hope for the PC if Mr Jerrard and his “friends” stand and get re-elected.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (24th Mar 2019 @ 18:08:11)

Penny, I agree. By the way, I am not you, and I am certainly not having a conversation with myself. If I did that, I would probably forget who I was in the first place.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Anon2 (26th Mar 2019 @ 06:54:42)

For those who do not know, Nomination papers for the Parish Council elections have to be in to East Hampshire District Council by Wednesday 3rd April 2019, no later than 4pm.

I think you should be able to get an application form at the Parish Office in Midhurst Road.

A link to the East Hampshire District giving details is:

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Marian (26th Mar 2019 @ 09:48:31)

It still hasn't been explained how Dawn is the holder of so much confidential information when she hasn't been on the Parish Council for years.

Re: Parish Council Elections 2019
- Jane Ives (26th Mar 2019 @ 19:51:44)

I went to the very poorly attended Annual Parish Meeting last night which might be a reflection of the general apathy among residents about the parish council. We had nearly 100 people there last year.
But from speaking to others over the last couple of days it would appear there are some new people standing for election this time around so that's really good news.
I would urge anyone who is thinking about it to get their nomination form in to EHDC. It would be great to have a proper election where we actually get a choice rather than automatic election of those who stand.

Reply to THIS thread
Talkback Home

Please contact us with any changes to entries, or posts that you feel should be removed, ensuring that you include the posts subject. All messages here are © 1999 - 2019 Liphook Ltd and must not be reproduced elsewhere without permission.

building, preservation & maintenance

Liphook Carpet Warehouse - Station Road, GU30 7DR

Wills, LPAs & Probate Employment Law Dispute Resolution Company & Commercial Solicitors

D P M Leadwork Ltd provide a wide range of domestic and commercial lead roofing and roof tiling services in Liphook, Hampshire and surrounding areas.

Liphook Tree Surgeons offer a full range of arboricultural services from planting right through to felling and stump grinding.

Get 50 cash bulb when swapping to Bulb energy

© 1999 - 2019 Liphook Ltd Supported by DG & YSH Hosting
This website is owned and operated by Liphook Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales - company number: 07468258.